There is currently no credible evidence confirming that Judith is not Geoff Toovey’s biological child, nor evidence confirming the allegation that Winifred Toovey had a relationship with another former Manly Sea Eagles player.
Toovey remains one of Manly’s most respected figures, having enjoyed a distinguished playing career with the club before later serving as a coach.
The claims circulating online should therefore be treated as unverified allegations rather than confirmed news. Until credible evidence or an official statement becomes available, it would be inappropriate to identify another person as an alleged biological father or affair partner.