In 2025, Preston Mattingly, General Manager of the Philadelphia Phillies, expressed strong reservations about signing a new key player to replace Alec Bohm at third base, despite some speculation about the team needing to find a long-term solution for the position. Mattingly, known for his methodical and data-driven approach, emphasized that Bohm’s performance and potential for growth with the Phillies should not be underestimated.
Mattingly pointed to Bohm’s steady improvement over the years, particularly his growing consistency with the bat and his defense, which had shown noticeable strides in the past season. He argued that replacing Bohm with an external player, even one with star potential, would disrupt the team’s chemistry and potentially stunt the development of a player who still had room to grow into a top-tier MLB talent.
“The key to success in this league is not just signing big names or making splashy moves, but also trusting in the players you have,” Mattingly said. “Alec Bohm has shown he can handle the pressure of a major market like Philadelphia, and his ability to adapt and improve should not be overlooked.”
Furthermore, Mattingly raised concerns about the long-term financial commitment required to sign an external star third baseman. With several other areas of need on the roster, including bullpen depth and outfield consistency, Mattingly argued that it would be wiser to continue developing Bohm, utilizing the resources elsewhere, and keeping flexibility within the payroll.
Ultimately, Mattingly’s stance was clear: the team’s investment in Bohm was still valuable, and the focus in 2025 should be on further strengthening other positions rather than seeking an immediate replacement at third base.
